Set the four domestic futures grades side by side on 16 November and the directions do not line up. Fuel oil gained 1.41 to ¥4,169 a tonne, butadiene rubber added 2.4 to ¥16,190, natural rubber rose 0.33 to ¥19,620, while bitumen fell 0.34 to ¥4,360.
Fuel oil and bitumen both sit downstream of heavy crude yet moved opposite ways. Their feedstock cost follows oil, but demand diverges: fuel oil tracks bunkering and power-generation restocking, bitumen follows the seasonal rhythm of road work. Folding both into one line about a strong heavy-fuel chain throws away the useful part of the signal. What actually happened is demand divergence, not a shared cost push.
The two rubber grades are uneven as well. Butadiene rubber up 2.4 ran well ahead of natural rubber at 0.33, pointing to a driver in inputs such as butadiene rather than a broad tyre-demand recovery. The purchasing implication is concrete: products built mainly on natural rubber and those built on butadiene rubber will not face the same cost pressure over the coming weeks. A single inventory call across thirteen categories no longer holds. Splitting the procurement window along the heavy-fuel and rubber curves fits the tape better.